The list of names of priests who have served in the Diocese of Steubenville and have been credibly accused of at least one act of sexual abuse of a minor consists of:
Cletus Altermatt, suspended from ministry in 1962 (deceased);
Elwood Bernas, suspended from ministry in 1986;
Kenneth P. Bonadies, suspended from ministry Sept. 11, 2018, by the Archdiocese of Hartford, Connecticut, and added to their credibly accused list in April 2021 (deceased);
Robert A. Brown (deceased);
Vincent Danko, suspended from ministry in 1971 (deceased);
H. Christopher Foxhoven, suspended from ministry Oct. 27, 2018, dismissed from the clerical state by Pope Francis March 26, 2020;
Mark J. Froehlich, removed from ministry May 22, 2018; the investigation has deemed these accusations credible but not substantiated;
Harold Goschke, suspended from ministry in 1957 (deceased);
Kenneth Harris, suspended from ministry in 1963 (deceased);
Michael Hellmer, suspended from ministry in 1989 (deceased);
John “Jack” Holmes, suspended from ministry in 1989 (deceased);
Anthony Jablonowski, suspended from ministry in 2003, dismissed from the clerical state by Pope Benedict XVI in 2006;
Robert F. Marrer, deceased;
Joseph A. Martinkosky, suspended from ministry in 1991;
John Nadzam, suspended from ministry in 2004 (deceased);
Walter Plimmer, suspended from ministry in 1956 (deceased);
Francis Rothbauer, suspended from ministry in 1998 (deceased);
Joel Wright, pre-theology seminarian, who never became a candidate for ordination; dismissed as a seminarian in January 2016, convicted in July 2016;
Gary Zalenski, suspended from ministry in 2007, dismissed from the clerical state as a result of an ecclesiastical trial in 2014.
Any religious order priests were not included, because they are under the jurisdiction of their religious order superiors.